Chapter Three

## Strange Phenomena

Optical illusions, weird science, and things that shouldn't be

Strange phenomena surround us at every turn, quietly defying our expectations of what the world should be. A glowing orb drifts across a stormy landscape and vanishes. A patient recovers from illness because they believe they have been treated. Hot water reaches the freezing point before cold water does, violating every intuition about thermodynamics. These are not parlor tricks or exaggerations — they are documented, repeatable, and in many cases still without full scientific explanation. This chapter gathers together the most bewildering phenomena that nature and the human mind have produced, each one a reminder that the universe is far stranger than we tend to assume.

Lightning in its ordinary form is terrifying enough. Ball lightning is something else entirely. Photo: Unsplash

## Ball Lightning

Of all the phenomena catalogued in this chapter, perhaps none has been more stubbornly resistant to explanation than ball lightning. Witnesses across centuries and continents describe the same basic sequence: during or just after a thunderstorm, a luminous sphere — typically between 10 and 40 centimetres in diameter, though reports range from pea-sized to over a metre — appears, floats through the air for several seconds, and then either fades away silently or explodes with a sharp bang. The spheres are typically white, yellow, or orange, and they move slowly enough to be tracked by eye. They have been observed passing through glass windows, drifting down the aisles of aircraft, and even entering buildings through open doors, only to exit through walls.

One of the earliest known written accounts comes from the English monk Gervase of Canterbury, dated 1195, though descriptions of similar phenomena appear in other medieval sources, though the phenomenon is almost certainly far older. In 1753, the Russian scientist Georg Richmann was killed by ball lightning while attempting to take measurements from his lightning rod apparatus with a lightning rod — one of the few confirmed fatalities. Modern surveys suggest that Surveys have found that roughly 3 to 6 per cent of respondents has observed ball lightning at some point, implying millions of witnesses worldwide.

Dozens of theories have been proposed. Some physicists argue that ball lightning is a plasma phenomenon — a pocket of ionized gas stabilized by electromagnetic fields. Others propose that it results from the vaporization of silicon in soil struck by ordinary lightning, forming a glowing aerosol. A third camp suggests microwave resonance within thunderclouds creates standing waves that produce localized luminosity. None of these theories fully accounts for all the reported behaviors. The phenomenon remains, as one researcher put it, "one of the most stubbornly unresolved problems in classical physics."

"The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not 'Eureka!' but 'That's funny...'"

— Isaac Asimov

A sugar pill, prescribed with authority, can relieve real pain. The placebo effect is not imaginary — it is physiological. Photo: Unsplash

## The Placebo Effect

If a doctor hands you a pill and tells you it will reduce your pain, there is a reasonable chance that it will — even if the pill contains nothing but sugar. This is the placebo effect, and it is among the most well-documented phenomena in all of medical science. Across hundreds of randomized controlled trials, placebo treatments have been shown to relieve pain, reduce inflammation, ease symptoms of Parkinson's disease and depression, lower blood pressure, and even cause measurable changes in brain activity. The effect is not limited to pills: placebo surgery, placebo injections, and placebo acupuncture have all demonstrated measurable effects.

The mechanisms are multiple and complex. Expectation plays a central role — patients who believe a treatment will work tend to experience greater benefit. Classical conditioning also contributes: if you have previously experienced relief from a medication, a similar-looking pill can trigger the same physiological response. Brain imaging studies show that placebos activate the same regions — the prefrontal cortex, the anterior cingulate, the periaqueductal gray — that are activated by actual analgesics. The body, it seems, has its own pharmacy, and belief is the prescription that unlocks it.

#### The Nocebo Effect

The placebo effect has a dark twin. When patients expect negative outcomes, they often experience them. In one remarkable study, participants told that a (harmless) cream might cause itchiness and redness developed genuine rashes at the application site. In clinical trials, the nocebo effect accounts for a significant share of reported side effects — even among patients receiving the placebo. The mind's power to heal is matched only by its power to harm.

Perhaps the most striking aspect of the placebo effect is that it appears to be growing stronger over time. Analyses of clinical trials conducted since the 1960s show that the placebo response in pain trials has increased steadily, particularly in the United States. Researchers attribute this partly to more elaborate trial procedures and partly to the direct-to-consumer advertising of pharmaceuticals, which has amplified patients' expectations of drug efficacy.

## Synesthesia

Imagine tasting words. Imagine hearing colors. Imagine seeing the number 7 as an unmistakable shade of turquoise, or feeling the touch of a texture whenever you hear a musical note. For roughly 4% of the population, these experiences are not imaginary — they are automatic, consistent, and lifelong. This is synesthesia, a neurological phenomenon in which stimulation of one sensory or cognitive pathway automatically and involuntarily triggers a second pathway.

The most common form is grapheme-color synesthesia, in which individual letters or numbers are perceived as inherently colored. For these synesthetes, the letter A might always appear red, or the number 3 might always be yellow. The associations are remarkably stable over time: test a grapheme-color synesthete once, then retest them decades later, and the pairings will be nearly identical. Other well-documented forms include chromesthesia (sound-to-color), lexical-gustatory (word-to-taste), and mirror-touch synesthesia, in which observing someone else being touched triggers a felt sensation of touch on the synesthete's own body.

Far from being a disorder, synesthesia is now understood as a harmless — and often beneficial — variant of human perception. Synesthetes frequently excel at memory tasks, as the additional sensory dimensions provide richer encoding. Many celebrated artists, musicians, and writers have been synesthetes, including Vladimir Nabokov, Olivier Messiaen, and David Hockney. Neuroimaging studies reveal that synesthetic experiences correspond to genuine activation in the relevant cortical regions: when a synesthete hears a note and "sees" a color, both the auditory cortex and the visual cortex light up. The experience, in other words, is real in every neurological sense.

#### Did You Know?

The word synesthesia comes from the Greek syn (together) and aisthesis (sensation). The first medical description of coloured hearing dates to an 1812 thesis by the German physician Georg Tobias Ludwig Sachs, though the term itself came into medical use in the late nineteenth century, though descriptions of colored hearing appear in the writings of John Locke in 1690. The condition runs strongly in families and is once thought to be far more common in women than in men, though more recent research finds the gap may be much smaller than previously believed. Genetic studies suggest synesthesia has a heritable component, though the specific genes involved remain under investigation.

## The Mpemba Effect

### Why Hot Water Can Freeze Faster Than Cold

In 1963, a Tanzanian secondary school student named Erasto Mpemba was making ice cream in his cooking class. He noticed that warm milk-and-sugar mixture, placed directly into the freezer, froze more quickly than a cold mixture. His teachers told him he was mistaken. He persisted. When the physicist Denis Osborne visited his school, Mpemba asked him why hot water freezes faster than cold water. Osborne investigated, replicated the result, and in 1969 they co-authored a paper that gave the phenomenon its name.

The Mpemba effect is deeply counterintuitive. If hot water must cool through the temperature that cold water starts at, how can it possibly reach the freezing point first? And yet, under the right conditions, it does. The effect has been observed in repeated experiments, though it is sensitive to the specifics of the setup — container shape, water volume, cooling rate, and the presence of dissolved gases all appear to matter.

Several explanations have been proposed over the decades. Evaporation reduces the volume of hot water, leaving less to freeze. Convection currents in hot water create temperature gradients that accelerate cooling. Supercooling effects cause cold water to remain liquid below 0°C longer than hot water. Dissolved gases, which escape from hot water, may alter the freezing point. More recently, researchers have proposed that the strength of hydrogen bonds in warm water — which stretch before breaking — may allow faster energy dissipation. As of now, no single explanation has achieved consensus, and the Mpemba effect remains one of the most celebrated puzzles in thermal physics.

- Aristotle noted the effect in the 4th century BC, writing: "The fact that the water has previously been warmed contributes to its freezing quickly."
- Francis Bacon observed in 1620: "Slightly warm water freezes more easily than that which is entirely cold."
- René Descartes wrote in 1637: "Experiments show that water which has been kept hot for a long time freezes faster than any other sort."
- The Royal Society of Chemistry held a competition in 2012 to explain the Mpemba effect. Over 22,000 people entered. No decisive winner was declared.

A ferrofluid responds to a magnet by forming spiky towers — each one a balance between magnetic force and surface tension. Photo: Unsplash

## Ferrofluid

Imagine a liquid that dances. That climbs. That bristles into a landscape of terrifying, beautiful spikes the instant a magnet comes near. This is ferrofluid — a suspension of nanoscale magnetic particles in a carrier liquid (typically oil or water), coated with a surfactant that prevents the particles from clumping. The result is a jet-black, highly responsive fluid that behaves as though it were alive when exposed to a magnetic field.

Each particle in a ferrofluid is roughly 10 nanometers across — small enough that thermal motion keeps them from settling under gravity. When a magnetic field is applied, the particles align with the field lines, and the fluid as a whole moves to follow. The spiky formations that appear on the surface of a ferrofluid are not random: they are an exact physical expression of the field's geometry, each spike representing a point where the magnetic force pulling the fluid upward exactly balances the surface tension and gravity pulling it flat. The pattern is called a rosenzweig instability, after the physicist who first described it mathematically.

Developed in the 1960s by NASA scientist Steve Papell, ferrofluid was originally intended as a way to control liquid rocket fuel in zero gravity. Today it is used in a remarkable range of applications: as a sealant in hard disk drives, as a contrast agent in magnetic resonance imaging (though most ferrofluid-based agents have since been withdrawn from the market), in loudspeakers to dampen vibrations, and In experimental medicine, ferrofluid is being investigated for targeted cancer treatment, where it would be guided by magnets to tumour sites and then heated to destroy malignant cells. Artists have also embraced ferrofluid for its extraordinary visual properties, creating kinetic sculptures and interactive installations that make magnetic fields visible to the naked eye.

## Bioluminescence

In the deepest parts of the ocean, where no sunlight has ever reached, the water glows. Bioluminescence — the production of light by living organisms — is one of nature's most widespread and yet least understood phenomena. It has evolved independently at least ninety times across the tree of life, appearing in bacteria, fungi, dinoflagellates, insects, fish, squid, jellyfish, and crustaceans. In the deep sea, where it is most common, an estimated 76% of pelagic taxa include bioluminescent species.

The chemistry is elegant in its simplicity. An organic molecule called luciferin is oxidized by the enzyme luciferase, releasing energy in the form of a photon of light. Different organisms use different luciferins and luciferases, which is why bioluminescence appears in colors ranging from blue-green to yellow to red. Cold light, it is called — highly efficient — converting as much as 90 to 95 per cent of chemical energy into visible light at converting chemical energy into visible light, compared to roughly 5 to 10 per cent efficiency for an incandescent bulb and 15 to 25 per cent for a fluorescent lamp. No heat. No waste. Just light.

Organisms use bioluminescence for a dazzling array of purposes. The anglerfish dangles a glowing lure from its forehead to attract prey in the deep ocean's perpetual darkness. Fireflies blink in coded patterns to attract mates. Dinoflagellates flash when disturbed by passing waves or swimming animals, a defense mechanism thought to startle predators or attract even larger predators to eat the original attacker. The Hawaiian bobtail squid carries a colony of bioluminescent bacteria in a specialized light organ, using their glow to eliminate its silhouette against the moonlit surface and avoid being spotted by predators below — a living cloaking device, refined over millions of years of natural selection.

#### Did You Know?

During World War II, the Japanese military collected dried umihotaru (sea fireflies) and used them as emergency light sources — a handful of the dried crustaceans, moistened, could produce enough blue-green light to read a map without being visible to enemy aircraft. The idea was reportedly suggested by a soldier who had observed the creatures glowing on coastal rocks as a child. The sea remembers everything.

## The Baader-Meinhof Phenomenon

### When the Universe Seems to Be Paying Attention

You learn a new word, and within a week it appears in three different conversations, a novel you are reading, and a headline. You buy a blue car, and suddenly the road seems full of blue cars. You read about an obscure 1970s militant group, and then their name crops up in a documentary, a podcast, and a friend's offhand reference — all in the same month. You have not encountered the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon. Or rather, you have — and now you will encounter its name everywhere.

The Baader-Meinhof phenomenon, also known as the frequency illusion, is a cognitive bias in which, after noticing something for the first time, you begin to notice it with disproportionate frequency. It is not that the thing has become more common — it is that your brain has begun selectively attending to it. The phenomenon has two components: selective attention, which directs your cognitive resources toward the newly salient stimulus, and confirmation bias, which reinforces the impression that the stimulus is appearing more often by ignoring all the times it does not.

The name comes from the Baader-Meinhof Group (also known as the Red Army Faction), a left-wing militant organization active in West Germany. In a now-lost internet discussion from the mid-1990s, a participant noted that after first learning about the group, they began encountering references to it repeatedly — and the label stuck. The irony is delicious: learning about a phenomenon named after a phenomenon of learning about things and then noticing them repeatedly is itself a demonstration of the phenomenon.

Earthquake lights have been reported for centuries — luminous phenomena that appear in the sky before or during seismic events. Photo: Unsplash

## Earthquake Lights

Minutes before an earthquake strikes, witnesses have sometimes observed something extraordinary: glowing orbs, sheets of light, or luminous columns rising from the ground or appearing in the sky above the affected area. These are earthquake lights, and they have been documented (in one form or another) for over a thousand years. A Japanese scroll from the 9th century depicts "strange light in the sky" before a major quake. European observers in the 17th and 18th centuries described "flashes like torches" and "luminous bands" accompanying seismic events in Italy. In the 20th century, photographs and video recordings have captured what appear to be genuine luminous phenomena associated with earthquakes in Mexico, Japan, and elsewhere.

The mechanisms remain debated, but the leading hypothesis involves stress on crystalline rocks. When tectonic stress builds to a critical level, the mechanical deformation of certain minerals (particularly quartz) can generate electrical charges through the piezoelectric effect. These charges may ionize air molecules near the ground, producing visible light. Alternatively, rising gases released from stressed rock — including radon — might ionize the atmosphere. Some researchers have proposed that the lights result from rapidly changing magnetic fields generated by seismic activity, which could excite atmospheric gases in the same way that auroral displays are produced.

Regardless of the mechanism, earthquake lights represent a tantalizing possibility: if they reliably precede seismic events, they could serve as a warning system. A 2014 analysis of 65 documented earthquake light events found that the lights appeared, on average, seconds to minutes before the quake, though in some cases they were reported hours or even days in advance. The challenge is that the conditions under which they appear are not yet fully understood, making the phenomenon too unpredictable to serve as a practical early-warning tool — at least for now.

## The Sailing Stones of Death Valley

### Rocks That Move Alone

On the flat, cracked surface of Racetrack Playa — a dried lakebed in Death Valley National Park, California — heavy stones, some weighing over 300 kilograms, leave long trails etched into the ground behind them. The trails stretch for tens of meters, curving and sometimes doubling back on themselves. No one is pushing them. No animals are dragging them. There are no tread marks, no footprints, no signs of human intervention. For decades, the sailing stones of Racetrack Playa were one of the American West's most persistent natural mysteries.

First scientifically documented in the late 1940s, though spotted by prospectors earlier in the century, the stones' movement was a subject of intense speculation. Some researchers proposed that strong winds alone were responsible — the playa is notorious for gusts that can exceed 140 km/h. But the math was unconvincing: it would take sustained hurricane-force winds to move the heaviest stones, and no one had ever observed the rocks in motion. Other hypotheses invoked magnetic forces, gravitational anomalies, and even supernatural explanations. The most promising theory, suggested by geologist Robert Sharp in the 1970s, involved a combination of wind and thin sheets of ice that might form on the playa's surface during winter nights, providing a low-friction surface over which the stones could slide.

The mystery was finally solved in 2014, when a team led by paleoclimatologist Richard Norris placed GPS-equipped stones on the playa and set up a time-lapse camera system. What they captured was extraordinary. On winter nights, a thin layer of ice forms on the shallow ephemeral pond that covers part of the playa. As the sun rises and the ice begins to break up, the wind pushes large sheets of ice — and the ice sheets push the rocks embedded within them, causing them to slide slowly across the muddy surface at speeds of roughly 3 to 5 meters per minute. The trails are carved by the rocks dragging through the soft sediment beneath the water. The solution was elegant, but the phenomenon itself remains no less wondrous: to see it, you need perfect conditions — water, ice, sun, and wind — all arriving in the right sequence. The playa knows the schedule, even if we do not.

#### By the Numbers: Racetrack Playa

- Elevation: 1,132 m (3,714 ft) above sea level
- Playa dimensions: Approximately 4.5 km long, 2 km wide
- Heaviest documented moving stone: ~320 kg (700 lb)
- Longest recorded trail: ~880 m (2,900 ft)
- Average winter temperature: 3°C (37°F) — just cold enough
- Annual rainfall: Approximately 75 to 100 mm (3 to 4 in) — just wet enough

§ § §

## In Summary

The phenomena gathered in this chapter share something essential: each one resists easy explanation, and each one rewards close attention. Ball lightning, the Mpemba effect, and earthquake lights remind us that physics is not a finished book — there are chapters yet to be written. The placebo effect and synesthesia reveal that the boundary between body and mind is far more porous than we once assumed. The Baader-Meinhof phenomenon shows how much of what we perceive is shaped by what we have learned to notice. Ferrofluid and bioluminescence demonstrate that matter and life are capable of astonishments that outstrip the human imagination. And the sailing stones of Death Valley prove that even the most inexplicable phenomena, given enough patience and the right instruments, can be understood — though understanding them only makes them more remarkable.

Strange phenomena do not mean a broken universe. They mean a universe that continues to exceed our models.